- Published on
Reparations Deserve a Seat at the Table
As a white woman of privilege, reparations to provide race and social justice gave me pause at first. Really, you just pay people off and that solves the problem? But as a mediator and as a human being, I know it's time to challenge my own biases. And it's time to urge others to consider reparations as one of the viable solutions to racial injustice when engaged in mediation or other forms of conflict resolution.
On a large scale, reparations compensate people and communities for something that cannot be returned. Countries pay reparations when lives have been lost, communities destroyed or rights violated.[1] Like compensatory damages in a legal context, reparations are meant to return the wronged to where they were, prior to the wrongdoing.
One example is the 1988 Civil Liberties Act. This law made reparations available to Japanese Americans forcibly removed from their homes and placed in internment camps during World War II.[2] Similarly, reparations should be an option to right the wrongs of slavery, Jim Crow laws, redlining and mass incarceration.[3]
Some localities have already begun paying reparations. Georgetown University is one such example. Because they sold slaves in the 1830s, they decided to pay reparations to their descendants. And Chicago is another example. They passed a law providing reparations for hundreds of African Americans tortured by the police. [4] Chicago's law not only provides financial compensation to past victims, but also money for public memorials and mental health and education programs. Presently there is a bill before Congress to pay reparations on a national level.[5]
In workplace or community mediation where race and social justice are at issue, reparations might be a proposed solution. A wronged party might want the organization to fund projects that benefit their community for example.
Through mediation and facilitated dialogue, people can freely discuss the pros and cons of their ideas. A good mediator will move the conversation forward by asking questions and encouraging the parties to explore rather than dismiss the possibilities.
The question is not whether reparations should be an option but how reparations play into the bigger picture of resolving the racial divide and providing social justice.
On a large scale, reparations compensate people and communities for something that cannot be returned. Countries pay reparations when lives have been lost, communities destroyed or rights violated.[1] Like compensatory damages in a legal context, reparations are meant to return the wronged to where they were, prior to the wrongdoing.
One example is the 1988 Civil Liberties Act. This law made reparations available to Japanese Americans forcibly removed from their homes and placed in internment camps during World War II.[2] Similarly, reparations should be an option to right the wrongs of slavery, Jim Crow laws, redlining and mass incarceration.[3]
Some localities have already begun paying reparations. Georgetown University is one such example. Because they sold slaves in the 1830s, they decided to pay reparations to their descendants. And Chicago is another example. They passed a law providing reparations for hundreds of African Americans tortured by the police. [4] Chicago's law not only provides financial compensation to past victims, but also money for public memorials and mental health and education programs. Presently there is a bill before Congress to pay reparations on a national level.[5]
In workplace or community mediation where race and social justice are at issue, reparations might be a proposed solution. A wronged party might want the organization to fund projects that benefit their community for example.
Through mediation and facilitated dialogue, people can freely discuss the pros and cons of their ideas. A good mediator will move the conversation forward by asking questions and encouraging the parties to explore rather than dismiss the possibilities.
The question is not whether reparations should be an option but how reparations play into the bigger picture of resolving the racial divide and providing social justice.
[1] Weiner, Brian A. “Sins of the Parents” Temple University Press (2005)
[2] 102 Stat. 904, 50a U.S.C. § 1989b et seq. https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/100/hr442
[3] Ta-Nehesi Coates makes the case for reparations in his article in the Atlantic Monthly. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/.
[4] https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/01/31/slavery-reparations-seem-impossible-many-places-theyre-already-happening/?arc404=true
[5] H.R. 40, the Commission to Study and Develop Reparation Proposals for African-Americans Act https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/40
[2] 102 Stat. 904, 50a U.S.C. § 1989b et seq. https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/100/hr442
[3] Ta-Nehesi Coates makes the case for reparations in his article in the Atlantic Monthly. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/.
[4] https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/01/31/slavery-reparations-seem-impossible-many-places-theyre-already-happening/?arc404=true
[5] H.R. 40, the Commission to Study and Develop Reparation Proposals for African-Americans Act https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/40
- Published on
You’re working from home due to the Coronavirus Pandemic and your co-worker just shot you a condescending and disrespectful reply to your latest communication. Angry, you’re tempted to shoot back just as nasty a reply as you can think of. But you know better and decide to calm down and think about it first. So you carefully craft a reply that you think is assertive but not too strong. Whoa, back comes an angry response that now they are really ticked off. What to do? Forward it to your supervisor? What’s going on here anyway?
We’re facing a brand new world of virtual communication. Deciding to stop the email barrage and walking two doors down to talk in person may not be an option in these times. So instead try some of these things:
Sometimes it might feel like nothing works. Or maybe there has been a pattern and this is just a culmination. If so, it may be time to involve a neutral third party as a conflict coach to help ease the communications and put you back on the right road. Call or email me today. I have helped numerous people finally find the words they need to get back on the right track.
We’re facing a brand new world of virtual communication. Deciding to stop the email barrage and walking two doors down to talk in person may not be an option in these times. So instead try some of these things:
- Check your perception, instead of getting defensive
- Use empathy, maybe they are having a bad day or maybe you did do something that made their work harder
- Use good problem solving skills, make a suggestion about what you would rather they have said, and solicit their input on how both of you can communicate better.
Sometimes it might feel like nothing works. Or maybe there has been a pattern and this is just a culmination. If so, it may be time to involve a neutral third party as a conflict coach to help ease the communications and put you back on the right road. Call or email me today. I have helped numerous people finally find the words they need to get back on the right track.
- Published on
When she proudly showed her business partner her latest logo design after a long series of rejected attempts, Janice made a face and Sandra said,
“How can you not like it?”
“I told you before that concept doesn’t work for me”
“What’s with you???”
Janice, feeling her anger rise, turned her back and walked away. Sandra picked up the phone and dialed her spouse who listened as she vented her frustration and said once again “Maybe its time for you to get out before things get even worse”.
Is that the best way to solve the problem? Fight, flight, or give in are not your only choices. Escalating the conflict may end you in court, while quitting costs you both financially and emotionally, and conflict has a way of festering when its smoothed over. One or both people will start to recognize that their needs are not getting met and resentment will kick in leading people back to thinking that fight or flight are their only choices.
But there is a third way. Through mediation you can not only solve the problem at hand but learn skills for solving future disputes. Business partners, employees, supervisors and managers have all learned better ways of working through disagreements and conflict through mediation. Not only is the presenting problem solved, but the parties learn skills to deal with future disputes in a more productive way. Accord & Collaboration also offers training in conflict skills and conflict management to help people learn to solve problems in the workplace while maintaining important business relations.
Do yourself a favor and call 206-367-1994 for a consultation today.
“How can you not like it?”
“I told you before that concept doesn’t work for me”
“What’s with you???”
Janice, feeling her anger rise, turned her back and walked away. Sandra picked up the phone and dialed her spouse who listened as she vented her frustration and said once again “Maybe its time for you to get out before things get even worse”.
Is that the best way to solve the problem? Fight, flight, or give in are not your only choices. Escalating the conflict may end you in court, while quitting costs you both financially and emotionally, and conflict has a way of festering when its smoothed over. One or both people will start to recognize that their needs are not getting met and resentment will kick in leading people back to thinking that fight or flight are their only choices.
But there is a third way. Through mediation you can not only solve the problem at hand but learn skills for solving future disputes. Business partners, employees, supervisors and managers have all learned better ways of working through disagreements and conflict through mediation. Not only is the presenting problem solved, but the parties learn skills to deal with future disputes in a more productive way. Accord & Collaboration also offers training in conflict skills and conflict management to help people learn to solve problems in the workplace while maintaining important business relations.
Do yourself a favor and call 206-367-1994 for a consultation today.
- Published on
“I didn’t do anything wrong!” “Well I didn’t do anything wrong either!” was the quick retort. Is that the end of the mediation? It is if the parties have come to mediation only to assess blame. But determining who is at fault and deciding who is right and who is wrong, is the responsibility of adjudicators and judges, not mediators.
When parties are stuck in the past and stuck in a blaming cycle, they narrow their choices. They can go to a judge or arbitrator, which in this country is costly and time consuming. Or they can ask someone else, to decide for them, losing control over their own dispute and sometimes only making one side very unhappy with the result leading to further resentment and sometimes even more conflict.
A good mediator will focus the parties on where they do agree, instead of where they disagree and move them to the future. They will focus on the what the parties need going forward rather than the facts of what occurred, including increasing the trust between the parties so that the conflict doesn’t arise again.
If you are stuck in a dispute, think about trying mediation. Call 206 367-1994 now or email for more information.
When parties are stuck in the past and stuck in a blaming cycle, they narrow their choices. They can go to a judge or arbitrator, which in this country is costly and time consuming. Or they can ask someone else, to decide for them, losing control over their own dispute and sometimes only making one side very unhappy with the result leading to further resentment and sometimes even more conflict.
A good mediator will focus the parties on where they do agree, instead of where they disagree and move them to the future. They will focus on the what the parties need going forward rather than the facts of what occurred, including increasing the trust between the parties so that the conflict doesn’t arise again.
If you are stuck in a dispute, think about trying mediation. Call 206 367-1994 now or email for more information.
- Published on
As reported in the Seattle Times recently, Gravity Payments co-founder Dan Price CEO, is facing a lawsuit brought by his brother and co-founder, Lucas Price. Profits that could be going to help fund Dan Price’s decision to pay his employees a living wage of $70,000/year may end up being used to pay litigation costs. Not to mention the relationship costs.
When family members disagree over business matters, emotions run high. As trust erodes, so does the relationship. But siblings don’t ever stop being siblings. When they don’t get along, family gatherings suffer. Parents and children suffer. Alienation and loss of community sets in.
Both brothers probably know this and usually when a lawsuit is filed between family members, it is not done without having tried to talk first. What many people still don’t know is that a mediator can make a big difference in helping the parties resolve highly emotional issues they haven’t been able to resolve themselves while saving them time, money and further emotional distress. A mediator skilled in communication techniques may be able to discover interests that underlie the reasons the suit was filed and help the parties work through the legal issues so that both sides feel like their rights as well as their feelings are being addressed.
Lawsuits are grueling and expensive affairs. Complaints are written to persuade a third party to award what is being sought, not to explain why offense was taken or negotiations broke down. In mediation, parties can discover what problems are beneath the surface, work on resolving those sometimes seemingly unrelated problems and smooth the way towards coming up with a solution that works for everyone.
More and more lawyers are realizing the benefits that early dispute resolution and mediation can provide their clients. Mediators who are also lawyers are becoming more sensitive to helping parties resolve not only the legal issues but to achieve psychological and procedural satisfaction as well.
When family members disagree over business matters, emotions run high. As trust erodes, so does the relationship. But siblings don’t ever stop being siblings. When they don’t get along, family gatherings suffer. Parents and children suffer. Alienation and loss of community sets in.
Both brothers probably know this and usually when a lawsuit is filed between family members, it is not done without having tried to talk first. What many people still don’t know is that a mediator can make a big difference in helping the parties resolve highly emotional issues they haven’t been able to resolve themselves while saving them time, money and further emotional distress. A mediator skilled in communication techniques may be able to discover interests that underlie the reasons the suit was filed and help the parties work through the legal issues so that both sides feel like their rights as well as their feelings are being addressed.
Lawsuits are grueling and expensive affairs. Complaints are written to persuade a third party to award what is being sought, not to explain why offense was taken or negotiations broke down. In mediation, parties can discover what problems are beneath the surface, work on resolving those sometimes seemingly unrelated problems and smooth the way towards coming up with a solution that works for everyone.
More and more lawyers are realizing the benefits that early dispute resolution and mediation can provide their clients. Mediators who are also lawyers are becoming more sensitive to helping parties resolve not only the legal issues but to achieve psychological and procedural satisfaction as well.
- Published on
Here's a video from the American Bar Association with a humorous take on the world of mediation. Let me know what you think!
- Published on
Emotions were running high. These two were each enraged by the other. Distrust pervaded the room. Both had just painted a picture of the other as ill intentioned and vindictive. Was there any way through this? My heart pumping, I plunged in. “You’re furious”, I said to Chris, “From your perspective, Pat is out to get you”. Chris, still angry, replied, “Absolutely and I won’t take it”. “You believe you deserve more respect than you’re getting” I said. “That’s right” was the retort.
I turned to Pat, “And you’re hopping mad, from where you sit it seems that Chris shows you no respect”. “You’ve got that right”, was the response. “Clearly respect is very important to both of you” I said. The two, a bit calmer now but still glaring at each other, nodded in agreement. As I continued to name the feeling and acknowledge their interest in respect, the tension in the room gradually began to subside. Eventually both calmed down and we began to talk about the issue that divided them, including the disrespect each felt from the other. Together they made a plan about how they would treat each other in the future and eventually they resolved the issue that resulted in their appearing before me as their mediator.
This story, although vastly simplified to make a point and with gender neutral fictitious names, is a drama that plays out often in mediation. With the help of a neutral third party mediator, a way through a situation headed to an all out battle can often be derailed. Deep in the emotions surrounding conflict, it is hard for people to acknowledge each other and discover what the other person really needs to move forward. Even someone who is not part of the conflict but who stands in a power position over one or both of the parties may have a hard time helping people feel safe enough to let down their guard and discover what they really need from each other. That is why mediation by a third party, who has no relationship to the parties in conflict, works so well. Next time you are involved in an intractable conflict at work or you see one that is hampering productivity, give me a call so that I can help analyze the situation and together decide if mediation is right for you.
This story, although vastly simplified to make a point and with gender neutral fictitious names, is a drama that plays out often in mediation. With the help of a neutral third party mediator, a way through a situation headed to an all out battle can often be derailed. Deep in the emotions surrounding conflict, it is hard for people to acknowledge each other and discover what the other person really needs to move forward. Even someone who is not part of the conflict but who stands in a power position over one or both of the parties may have a hard time helping people feel safe enough to let down their guard and discover what they really need from each other. That is why mediation by a third party, who has no relationship to the parties in conflict, works so well. Next time you are involved in an intractable conflict at work or you see one that is hampering productivity, give me a call so that I can help analyze the situation and together decide if mediation is right for you.
- Published on
What do you do when you’re feeling micro-managed? How do you react to a new boss or one who suddenly acts as if they don’t trust you anymore? Trust in the workplace is at the heart of many a conflict that has caused good workers to look elsewhere for work. Trust goes both ways.
Trust between managers and the employees they manage or supervise is critical for a high functioning organization. Managers need to give their employees some decision making power and then trust them not to abuse that power. For their part, employees must trust managers not to punish them for mistakes when they are trying to do the right thing for the organization. Research has shown that trust between employees and those formally responsible for their behavior has a positive effect on the organization’s financial performance.
So what do you do when you feel like your boss doesn’t trust you? Active listening may be a good place to start. Try starting a conversation about the discomfort you’re feeling. Describe a recent incident where you didn’t feel trusted. Be specific about the facts without judging the actions or words of the other person. Ask the other person for their reaction.
When the person has finished giving their reaction or explanation, check for understanding by paraphrasing what you’ve heard. You don’t need to repeat what they’ve said, simply summarize the main points and ask if you’ve got it right. This gives people an opportunity to clarify what they are trying to say and gives you the chance to see if the meaning you are hearing is what is being conveyed. If when they are finished you still don’t understand, ask clarifying open-ended questions, such as “Can you elaborate on what you mean by...”
Using these simple techniques will lead to more productive conversations and more trust in the workplace. If you and others in the workplace would like to learn more about how to establish and maintain trust in the workplace, call ACDRS and ask about our training series. For interpersonal conflicts that don’t seem to improve, ask about mediation. Through mediation, people can try new methods of communicating with each other in a safe environment. Don’t let mistrust build in your organization. Instead, take some steps today to move your workplace towards being a high functioning organization.
Trust between managers and the employees they manage or supervise is critical for a high functioning organization. Managers need to give their employees some decision making power and then trust them not to abuse that power. For their part, employees must trust managers not to punish them for mistakes when they are trying to do the right thing for the organization. Research has shown that trust between employees and those formally responsible for their behavior has a positive effect on the organization’s financial performance.
So what do you do when you feel like your boss doesn’t trust you? Active listening may be a good place to start. Try starting a conversation about the discomfort you’re feeling. Describe a recent incident where you didn’t feel trusted. Be specific about the facts without judging the actions or words of the other person. Ask the other person for their reaction.
When the person has finished giving their reaction or explanation, check for understanding by paraphrasing what you’ve heard. You don’t need to repeat what they’ve said, simply summarize the main points and ask if you’ve got it right. This gives people an opportunity to clarify what they are trying to say and gives you the chance to see if the meaning you are hearing is what is being conveyed. If when they are finished you still don’t understand, ask clarifying open-ended questions, such as “Can you elaborate on what you mean by...”
Using these simple techniques will lead to more productive conversations and more trust in the workplace. If you and others in the workplace would like to learn more about how to establish and maintain trust in the workplace, call ACDRS and ask about our training series. For interpersonal conflicts that don’t seem to improve, ask about mediation. Through mediation, people can try new methods of communicating with each other in a safe environment. Don’t let mistrust build in your organization. Instead, take some steps today to move your workplace towards being a high functioning organization.
- Published on
Yes, and “life’s not fair”. But where does that get you in the workplace? When people feel like their boss is treating them unfairly or a co-worker seemingly gets more privileges, complaints and grievances go up and morale goes down.
In our society, both individualism and equality are valued, but these values can clash when making decisions. Everyone thinks their situation is unique and justifies an exception to the rule. And rigid adherence to rules will garner its own problems.
So what does it mean to be fair? It may be fair to grant an exception. Or maybe it's more fair to adhere to a policy that applies evenly to all.
What fairness means may be different for everyone. Fairness means a measure against a standard of some kind. And standards can have many sources. Standards of fairness may come from the law. But what each of us considers fair may still vary because legal standards are not the only standards we have learned and that we may live by. We might use standards that we learned in our family (cultural standards). Some of us use standards that we learned in church (moral or religious standards). Others use standards that are a collection of acceptable practices (industry standards).
Because there are different sources of fairness, it can become a source of conflict. And because circumstances vary as much as personalities, this creates conflict but also opportunity. Alternate dispute resolution and mediation provide the opportunity to craft solutions that work for the unique situation and parties involved. The parties get to decide what is fair for them using the standards that are right for them and their circumstances. At the same time, if they can’t agree, settlement is entirely voluntary and no one loses the right to resort to a legal standard in court.
In our society, both individualism and equality are valued, but these values can clash when making decisions. Everyone thinks their situation is unique and justifies an exception to the rule. And rigid adherence to rules will garner its own problems.
So what does it mean to be fair? It may be fair to grant an exception. Or maybe it's more fair to adhere to a policy that applies evenly to all.
What fairness means may be different for everyone. Fairness means a measure against a standard of some kind. And standards can have many sources. Standards of fairness may come from the law. But what each of us considers fair may still vary because legal standards are not the only standards we have learned and that we may live by. We might use standards that we learned in our family (cultural standards). Some of us use standards that we learned in church (moral or religious standards). Others use standards that are a collection of acceptable practices (industry standards).
Because there are different sources of fairness, it can become a source of conflict. And because circumstances vary as much as personalities, this creates conflict but also opportunity. Alternate dispute resolution and mediation provide the opportunity to craft solutions that work for the unique situation and parties involved. The parties get to decide what is fair for them using the standards that are right for them and their circumstances. At the same time, if they can’t agree, settlement is entirely voluntary and no one loses the right to resort to a legal standard in court.
- Published on
Sometimes employers are so offended by a grievance or an EEOC complaint that they believe if they were to sit down and negotiate with the employee, they'd be selling their souls. Sometimes employees feel like entering into a negotiation with an employer who believes they have done nothing wrong would not only be futile but would increase their pain. And then there is that co-worker that has it in for you, why in the world would you sit down at a negotiating table with someone like that?
Principles drive many of us. When we're sure we're right about something, the very word "negotiation" seems like a dirty word. We might feel like the other side is only out to get us. If you're an employer, you might think that the employee is just a gold digger, and is looking only to see how much money they can get. If you're an employee you might feel that your employer is abusive and needs to be exposed in a public forum.
But what if you're wrong? What if the employee has a genuine grievance that you've just failed to see? What if your boss finally understood what you were trying to say? What if there is a solution out there that neither of you had thought of previously? In mediation, we call this "suspending judgment". It doesn't mean that the judgment isn't there, it means putting it aside for now and seeing if you attribute positive intent to the other side whether that might make a difference in the outcome.
Deciding that the other side is evil is sometimes our minds way of giving up. It might seem that there is no other explanation for the fact that our own unassisted efforts at negotiation have failed. But if two heads are better than one, three might be better yet. By involving a third party neutral, there is a chance not only for new creative solutions to arise, but a chance that a new third way of looking at the communication dynamics could come about.
If you are facing what seems like an intractable conflict in the workplace, give me a call. You might be surprised to find that its possible to replace those horns and tail with a workable solution and a better working relationship.
Principles drive many of us. When we're sure we're right about something, the very word "negotiation" seems like a dirty word. We might feel like the other side is only out to get us. If you're an employer, you might think that the employee is just a gold digger, and is looking only to see how much money they can get. If you're an employee you might feel that your employer is abusive and needs to be exposed in a public forum.
But what if you're wrong? What if the employee has a genuine grievance that you've just failed to see? What if your boss finally understood what you were trying to say? What if there is a solution out there that neither of you had thought of previously? In mediation, we call this "suspending judgment". It doesn't mean that the judgment isn't there, it means putting it aside for now and seeing if you attribute positive intent to the other side whether that might make a difference in the outcome.
Deciding that the other side is evil is sometimes our minds way of giving up. It might seem that there is no other explanation for the fact that our own unassisted efforts at negotiation have failed. But if two heads are better than one, three might be better yet. By involving a third party neutral, there is a chance not only for new creative solutions to arise, but a chance that a new third way of looking at the communication dynamics could come about.
If you are facing what seems like an intractable conflict in the workplace, give me a call. You might be surprised to find that its possible to replace those horns and tail with a workable solution and a better working relationship.